Periodically, along with others, I receive a mail fromBrianCave, who is running a campaign with the laudable aim of restoring the vote to those British citizens who under current legislation lose the right to vote inUKelections after living abroad for more than 15 years.
I’ve just received his latest mail, and am particularly interested in the section on what will happen in the case of a Brexit, which is of course a separate albeit related issue. Given that no-one can foretell the future with accuracy, I believe some of his predictions are questionable, to say the least. For ease of reference, I’ve set them out below, together with my responses
“British citizens will no longer be EU citizens”
We are British citizens, unless we want to change our citizenship to the country in which we live. EU citizenship is a mythical state.
“British citizens will no longer be free to work, set up businesses, study and retire in EU countries. British citizens will no longer benefit from subsidised health services across the EU.”
British citizens were doing all those things long before the EU came into being. Furthermore, those benefits are reciprocal, as is also the case with the NHS. There’s no reference to the Double Taxation Treaty, which is an example of an arrangement that exists quite independent of the EU.
“The Euro Health Insurance card 'EHIC' would cease to be available to British Citizens - So emergency health cover from Britain would cease for British holiday makers in Europe.”
There is no reason why it could not be replaced by a UKHIC. Again, there is the question of reciprocity to take into account.
“British citizens would not benefit from the reduced bureaucracy in EU countries that they currently enjoy as EU citizens.”
I suspect that he’s making bricks out of straw here, and have asked for examples.
“British citizens are likely to be subject to increased border checks when travelling in the EU.”
The way things are going, this is likely to happen in any case, and overall may in fact be an improvement on the current situation.
I’ve replied to him on those lines, but think that these issues should be the subject of wider debate, and shall be interested to read what others think on the subject.